A Guide To The Rumored Hookups Of ‘American Idol’

Second place 'Idol' contestant Justin Guarini was the total player of the house. He's rumored to have hooked up with Kelly, Christina and Tamyra, all behind the other girls' backs. Kelly Clarkson's "You Thought Wrong," which features Tamyra, is rumored to be about Justin.

Season 2, third-placer Kimberley Locke hooked up with producer Simon Lythgoe, son of show creator Nigel. She even often returned to the set the next year to hang out with Simon.

Paula came under a shitstorm of media fire Corey alleged an affair with the 'Idol' judge. Paula denied the allegations but the rumors persist.

Season 6 runner-up Blake Lewis had a rumored romance with fellow contestant Haley Scarnato that continued past the show's conclusion.

[Editor's Note: I am pretty sure Haley was engaged during her season. Scandalous!]

At the start of Season 6, Alaina and Chris apparently formed an instant connection and rumor has it they dated all season long.

Season 7, Irish contestant Carly was rumored to be hooking up with Australian contestant Michael, even though both were married.

Season 8 contestants Megan and Anoop denied rumors that they were dating despite being photographed canoodling in public.

Rumor has it Matt got pretty flirty with bikini contestant Katrina Darrell. We wonder if he got farther than America did.

Season 9 winner Lee apparently had a big-time crush on the awesome Siobhan. The two even got tattoos together.

The hot alleged couple of Season 10, Casey and Haley reportedly spend all their downtime cuddling and canoodling.