Subscribe
Take part in the discussion and find out who went home after the jump!
CARLY SMITHSON has been eliminated from American Idol.
Technorati Tags: american idol,american idol 7,carly smithson,results show,american idol 7 results,eliminated
Wednesday, April 23, 2008 - 3:53 pm ET
American Idol 7 Results Show - April 23, 2008
Wednesday, April 23, 2008 - 3:53 pm ET
Can’t believe it Carly is out
Still think Jason should be out…. Hmmm guess juz another Sanjaya case
So disappointed. I love David Cook (you noticed right? snort) but I also really liked Carly and she should NOT have gone home.
Really surprised by Carly’s elimination!
I am glad she went home.
David Cook = American Idol
I am sad to see Carly go home!!!!! But i think that syesha had a stronger voice…
I am really sad to see Carly go home!!! All the American Idols are really good this year and I still think it gets harder and harder each week!!! But Syesha has a really amazing voice~
Carly??? Why??
I can’t believe it. But…I love David Cook very must. The winner for American Idol 2008???? DAVID COOK!!!!
Carly didn’t deserve to go home this early! It should have been Jason or Brooke..i freakin’ hate those two’s performances.
True…. can’t wait to see Jason and Brooke to be out
I think everyone is on the same page that Jason should have been gone and so he’s a sure thing to get the boot next week. I vote for Brooke and Syesha so I’m not too disappointed and given that Carly was a strong performer that gives the hot babes a freebie week until they move into the top four with the two Davids. Then I think David A. won’t make it into the top three because his fans now make up less of a percentage. There are lots of people who would never vote for David A. who’s favorite is kicked off and they’ll go to anyone that’s not David A. Carly’s fans will go to David Cook or Syesha for example.
Brooke should be gone. She screwed up royally.
WHY?????
Jason rocks and he’s not EVER going “home,” because he’s going to be the next american idol – so either show some positive support, or keep the negativity to yourself!
OMG!!!! NOT CARLY:(
It should not have been Carly yet..
I think Carly should have had a couple more weeks EASILY. At my house, we were sure this was Brooke or Jason’s last week.
I feel sorry for those who don’t “get” Jason Castro. He’s a truly refreshing change from the “pump up the volume” pop singers of today.
Jayne – We can actualy express our opinions any way we like on this site as long as we are not vulgar or disrespectful, so if people do not like Jason’s vocals and express that here…so be it, it’s ok, calm down. He’s really not as strong as the others. He may be ok and in some opinions awesome but either way we have that right.
ozzy – I get what you are saying about Jason. Today’s Pop artists kind of all sound the same. Although I am not a big Jason fan…one never knows what can happen later
Have a good day Ozzy
i don’t understand!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Only reason why I watched the show was for Asia Cruise, Chakeezi, Syesha, and Carly. But it’s three down one to go. COME ON SYESHA, BRING IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Miss u already Carly, dang
…i can’t believe carly was eliminated, she’s really great, i mean she has a great voice, next to DAVID COOK…who happens to be MY AMERICAN IDOL….