Michael yelled at me – the song is not about yelling, it is about dreaming. Not good.

Syeesha committed tjhe mortal crime of singing another Idol’s coronation song. Does no one understand the rules of the show, she cannot win and must leave because she does not do homework. how she sounds is immaterial.

Justin was OK, I am not fond of the ukelale, for personal reasons, but was pretty much on key, but somewhat kareoke, as that song was reproduced note for note. Still being on key is good.

Krisy was at her best, but her best is not good enough, missed some notes.

I am not a conosuer of music, hence I did not know David C’s song, it sounded like a hot mess, he looked weird in a straight jacket (or was that from the “Monkees, hey, hey we’re the”
and who writes on their hand, except to cheat on tests in middle school?

Carly, hit some bad notes and let the Choir sing her glory note at the end. Did her voice fail her? maybe she shouldn’t scream some notes.

David A – well, his voice never appealed to me – the whole nasally thing reminded me of Chris Richards last year saying it was a style choice. I heard some bad notes, but I guess when you are David, it is not a bad thing. I thought the pieano playing was funny, I am sure he can play, but he was only playing a note here and there, I was watching his hands through part of it. Why bother?

Brooke was boring, nice song, snoozer. I have heard it done better by oh so many people.