American Idol 8 Top 7 Matt Giraud “Have You Ever Really Loved a Woman?”

Matt Giraud chose one of my very favorite love songs from the Don Juan DeMarco soundtrack and, I’m sorry, but I think he ruined it. The beginning was really nice and I thought it was going to go well but then he just overdid it and I hated it.

Randy said the performance was interesting – it started out well but then it went wrong during the bridge. Kara was providing commentary but I was too distracted by what Simon was doing behind her to pay attention. Did anyone see the weird (possibly obscene) mouth gestures he was making?!?