Skip to content
Tue, Mar 3 2009

American Idol Season 8 Top 36 – Scott MacIntyre

Scott MacIntyre, the first blind person to make it into the finals on American Idol, chose to sing “Mandolin Rain” which is a song that I’m not that familiar with. 

american idol season 8 top 36 - scott macintyreI am totally inspired by Scott’s courage and talent but I can’t lie.  I thought it was pretty good but not great.  Am I the only one who feels that way?  I feel like the judges are trying to push the viewers to vote for Scott because of his story rather than his vocals.

image © 2009 FOX BROADCASTING CR: Michael Becker / FOX

Around The Web
Share This Post:
  • email
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Tumblr
  • Reddit
Entertainment

Comments

  1. By Talia Forman

    Dearest Scott

    I want u to win tonight. Your special voices are reaching out to the ladies.

    You are such a hottie and i see it. It is glowing inside you i can see it all over.
    I’m looking forward to your concert tonight.
    I’m just dreaming about a perfect girl for you.

    I cant wait for tonight . You are a star that blooms like a flower.
    Good luck
    your fan
    Talia Forman

  2. Trackback
    1070 days ago
    American Idol Results – Lil, Scott and Jorge Make the Top 12

    [...] The second finalist based on last night’s performance show is Scott MacIntyre, the first blind contestant to make it to this stage in the competition.  He sang “Mandolin Rain.” [...]

  3. Trackback
    1071 days ago
    American Idol Season 8 Top 36 Performances – Group 3

    [...] American Idol Season 8 Top 36 – Scott MacIntyre [...]

  4. By Drew

    I completely agree about Scott. I loved the song choice (being a huge Hornsby fan) but it wasn’t the best vocal. Based on tonight alone, I don’t think he should make the top 12, but with his story who knows what may happen.