Comments on: Canadian Idol Live Blogging – August 27, 2007

By: Kimmy

Kimmy — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 21:01:52 +0000

weirdgrrl and Jeanne: I figured I couldn’t fault him this week because the hats fit with the theme, hehe. However, it occurred to me that quite oddly, no one on the show has made any comment about their ubiquitous presence. You’d think Ben would have made at least made a little jab about the hats by now. Conspiracy! lol ;)

By: Jeanne

Jeanne — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 20:32:38 +0000

Jay – that was a hilarious, to-the-point rundown of the remaining contestants. Thanks for that honesty!

Jaydeefan – I think I have to agree. Jaydee really does have a shot. :)

Weirdgrrl – I thought about it after I wrote the comment. If you do know the words, I can see how it could be overlooked, lol. My son said it sounded like lyrical diarrhea since he doesn’t know the songs. LOLOLOL!!! What a comment. He still thinks Carly’s smokin’ though. Oh and, yeah, there was plenty of meow meow in the comments last night but they were entertaining. No worries though – my tone is bad online and offline after a long day :)

By: weirdgrrl

weirdgrrl — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 18:13:28 +0000

I do understand what you mean by “slurry”, Jeanne, and I’ll listen for that next time. It might be that she just keeps picking songs that I know the words too already so I’m not necessarily paying attention to how she’s enunciating (or not enunciating) them.

And I’m glad the banter came off as entertaining and not b!tchy, as I’m not so good with tone when writing online at the end of a long day. :-)

By: jaydeefan

jaydeefan — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 16:52:06 +0000

yes, i actually do think he will win. go jaydee!

By: Jay Hennig

Jay Hennig — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 12:11:55 +0000

Carly Rae is a terrible singer..but cute
Jadee is the most fun to watch.
Dwight Can’t sing and his timing is always off..he’s gone…
Brain Melo…i can’t picture myself going to buy the “New” Brian Melo Album if there ever is one.
he’s too plain and not marketable enough.
Not a great singer.

By: Jeanne

Jeanne — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 06:50:09 +0000

Joshy – such hatred towards Dwight? I’ve never heard of anyone witholding the capitals in someone’s name for bad singing. That’s hilarious.

Lauren – I pretty much have to agree…yikes.

Marleen – Jaydee’s second performance was probably the highlight of the night for me. I agree – it did look like Dwight gave up tonight.

Kimmy – Did you see Brian changing up the hats??? LOL. I think you might be right about Dwight going home next week.

Liss – It’s great to hear from someone that was there live! I have wondered if they sound better in the auditorium than on television because some of the judges’ comments have baffled me all season. It all makes sense now – Thanks!

Kelly – Sexy cute? Jaydee? That’s great! I haven’t heard that one yet but I can see that. Especially since he didn’t smile tonight. He did his best to be “smoldering.” Hilarious!

Jaydeefan – It’s incredible. There are so many of you who love Jaydee. Do you think he will win?

weirdgrrl – I can’t explain it but I find some of Carly’s singing “slurry” but that doesn’t mean it’s bad. John Mayer is one of my favorites and when he sings live, he slurs. I can, however, believe that not all people see it that way. Good ears, my friend!
Good to see you’ve got good taste in music too! I laughed so hard when I read your comment about Jaydee (and the subsequent banter, lol).

By: Liss

Liss — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 06:24:47 +0000

LOL
‘aight, ‘aight..
the line was so perfect, i was so tempted to say it :P
i will let it be, no worries :)

By: weirdgrrl

weirdgrrl — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 06:22:03 +0000

Liss… I was trying to be diplomatic, but comments like yours could just tempt me to post my unpopular opinion. Just let it be, okay?

By: Liss

Liss — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 06:13:35 +0000

“And I will no longer comment about Jaydee”
its for the best.

By: weirdgrrl

weirdgrrl — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 06:07:50 +0000

I have to admit I’m confused by people saying they can’t understand Carly Rae when she sings because I’ve never had a problem with that. I thought her first song was okay but I loved her second song. She was so connected to it that I was moved.

And I thought Brian did well, too. First of all, he chose songs that I adore (I guess we’ve got that in common, Jeanne) and, apart from starting off a little shaky with Mack the Knife, I thought he did them both justice. I’m not saying he topped Nina Simone singing Feeling Good, but that’s a really hard song to sing and I felt it.

Poor Dwight was just completely out of his element. And I will no longer comment about Jaydee because I just don’t understand his appeal.

Hey Kimmy… did you notice that Brian managed to find two period style hats for tonight? LOL