Comments on: Canadian Idol Shock Elimination: Amberly Thiessen says good-bye http://crushable.com/entertainment/canadian-idol-shock-elimination-amberly-thiessen-says-good-bye/ Crushable gives you the celebrity news, style and scoop on the stuff you care about. Fri, 10 Feb 2012 15:44:18 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Bev http://crushable.com/entertainment/canadian-idol-shock-elimination-amberly-thiessen-says-good-bye/comment-page-1/#comment-260848 Bev Thu, 14 Aug 2008 12:35:45 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/canadian-idol-shock-elimination-amberly-thiessen-says-good-bye/#comment-260848 I wasn't so much shocked as I was furious for the way they did it. So unfair to let her think she was safe and then pull a stunt like that. I thought Ben had more class than that. She was so relieved when she wasn't one of the "bottom" 3. I WAS shocked that Theo and Mookie were in the "bottom" 3, I should have known there was a catch. I wasn’t so much shocked as I was furious for the way they did it. So unfair to let her think she was safe and then pull a stunt like that. I thought Ben had more class than that. She was so relieved when she wasn’t one of the “bottom” 3. I WAS shocked that Theo and Mookie were in the “bottom” 3, I should have known there was a catch.

]]> By: Jeanne http://crushable.com/entertainment/canadian-idol-shock-elimination-amberly-thiessen-says-good-bye/comment-page-1/#comment-260828 Jeanne Wed, 13 Aug 2008 18:34:32 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/canadian-idol-shock-elimination-amberly-thiessen-says-good-bye/#comment-260828 I really disliked her so I'm not shocked or saddened at all, lol! I really disliked her so I’m not shocked or saddened at all, lol!

]]> By: Grace http://crushable.com/entertainment/canadian-idol-shock-elimination-amberly-thiessen-says-good-bye/comment-page-1/#comment-259772 Grace Wed, 13 Aug 2008 18:08:35 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/canadian-idol-shock-elimination-amberly-thiessen-says-good-bye/#comment-259772 I wasn't shocked that she went home either, because she had been in the bottom three before. Also, I felt her performance was the weakest of the night (although many people don't vote based on the night's performance). I also am not sure if people vote based on who they think is most talented. I think it's partly regional voting, and partly based on who's style of singing they are into (and maybe who's personality they are drawn to). So, I don't think Amberly should take it personally, but just think of it as a sign that most voters (which doesn't mean most Canadians) prefer other styles of singing. I think Drew might be next. I think Drew has an incredible voice, but the judges really don't like him, and that has to influence voting. I wasn’t shocked that she went home either, because she had been in the bottom three before. Also, I felt her performance was the weakest of the night (although many people don’t vote based on the night’s performance). I also am not sure if people vote based on who they think is most talented. I think it’s partly regional voting, and partly based on who’s style of singing they are into (and maybe who’s personality they are drawn to). So, I don’t think Amberly should take it personally, but just think of it as a sign that most voters (which doesn’t mean most Canadians) prefer other styles of singing.

I think Drew might be next. I think Drew has an incredible voice, but the judges really don’t like him, and that has to influence voting.

]]> By: Melissa http://crushable.com/entertainment/canadian-idol-shock-elimination-amberly-thiessen-says-good-bye/comment-page-1/#comment-259773 Melissa Wed, 13 Aug 2008 17:43:19 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/canadian-idol-shock-elimination-amberly-thiessen-says-good-bye/#comment-259773 i was not shocked at all that amberly went home. i had a feeling that it would be her because she didnt do that great and she was 1st. i didnt want it to be amberly, i thought it was mitch's time to go home. poor amberly has WAY more talent than mitch yet has been in the bottom twice and went home, whereas mitch has never even been in the bottom before! to me thats not fair. sometimes i wonder what canada is thinking when theyre voting. theres always a shocking elimination every year where a talented one goes home at the expense of one with a bit less talent and its not fair at all. someone ought to do something about that voting system.. i was not shocked at all that amberly went home. i had a feeling that it would be her because she didnt do that great and she was 1st. i didnt want it to be amberly, i thought it was mitch’s time to go home. poor amberly has WAY more talent than mitch yet has been in the bottom twice and went home, whereas mitch has never even been in the bottom before! to me thats not fair. sometimes i wonder what canada is thinking when theyre voting. theres always a shocking elimination every year where a talented one goes home at the expense of one with a bit less talent and its not fair at all. someone ought to do something about that voting system..

]]>