Skip to content
Friday, September 5, 2008 - 10:22 am ET
  • Digg
  • email
  • Facebook
  • FriendFeed
  • StumbleUpon
  • Suggest to Techmeme via Twitter
  • Tumblr

Carrie Underwood Calls Jessica Simpson Fat?

American Idol 2008 Grand Finale - Arrivals

Can you believe this?  OK! Magazine is reporting that American Idol winner, Carrie Underwood, has some strong opinions about Jessica Simpson who is currently romantically linked to Carrie’s ex Tony Romo.  This comes after Jessica declared him “the love of her life” and claimed that she checks Tony’s phone logs and doesn’t believe Carrie and him still talk (as Carried has said in the past).  She also is allegedly unconcerned about having to compete with Jessica on the country music charts.  Here’s what “a friend” is reported to have said to OK!:

“She finds Jessica’s love of putting her life on display pretty desperate.  She laughed at the People cover, because it’s the same one Jess did about John Mayer — same smile, same look, except she’s a little fatter….

Carrie doesn’t think fans will spend money to watch Jess warble through a few badly written songs.”

Well, what do you think?  Did she say that?

Friday, September 5, 2008 - 10:22 am ET
  • Digg
  • email
  • Facebook
  • FriendFeed
  • StumbleUpon
  • Suggest to Techmeme via Twitter
  • Tumblr

24 Comments

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  1. kmac08

    Carrie is absolutely right about Jessica being desperate!! And she has nothing to worry about on the country OR pop charts, for that matter. Carrie is fabulous.

  2. b5media – Entertainment Channel Roundup

    [...] Idol’s Carrie Underwood is still reportedly engaged in a war or words with Jessica Simpson. Jessica is dating Carrie’s ex, Tony Romo and has recently jumped into [...]

  3. xomegg

    jessica simpson = WANNABE! carrie has REAL talent. and i’m sick of jessica trying to ruin carrie’s life. she needs to get it thru her “fatter” head that she’ll never be as good as carrie. and it’s stupid that she’s trying and that she’s so controlling with tony too. it’s so stupid. GROW UP JESSICA SIMPSON!!

  4. psbintl

    Carrie has nothing to worry about! Every time I hear or see Jessica sing I want to run!

  5. DavidB

    JS is a musical threat to noone.

    Oh, and you’ve totally misread that comment about fatter. That’s a quote from a friend, not from Carrie herself.

  6. Debbie

    One thing we know for sure about a lot of these so called entertainment magazines and TV “entertainment news” shows is that most of what they report is made up to sell copies. I bet Carrie could care less about Jessica and whoever her latest boyfriend is or what album she has released.

  7. Crystal

    I don’t believe Carrie said that but if she did, I agree with her opinion that Jessica’s love of putting her life on display is pretty desperate. However she needs to get her eyes check if she thinks Jessica is fat.

  8. Michelle

    I don’t believe that Carrie said that. I think a lot of these magazines just want to make money at the expense of others. If Carrie did say these things she’s right. Carrie is way more talented. Besides why would Carrie care about Tony Romo she’s got a new boyfriend who is way better looking. She deserves someone better than Tony.

  9. Anu

    PEOPLE CARRIE SAID SHE WAS FATTER NOT FAT! THERE IS A BIG DIFFERENCE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! GOSH AND Carrie is so much better than Jessica, she’s hard working, vegan and so much more! Carrie actually worked hard and got to where she is by her talent! She deserves every single award she got! Carrie is better than Jessica THE END

  10. monica

    i think carrie underwood is UGLY!!!!!!!! and she sux!! oooo carrie got her career from american idol. good for her jessica did it on her own! jessica is prettier, more talented, and overall BETTER. carrie really needs to shut up cuz as i recall she had to loose a bunch of lb’s cuz she was fat, and i still dont think shes skinny.

  11. Danielle Polihros

    i like how carrie underwood is calling jessica simpson fat even though shes the one who used to look like a fat pig .. carrie underwood is ugly and pathetic .. she was on american idol the worst show ever made .. how much talent does that fat ass really have ?

  12. Carrie Underwood Didn’t Mean to Hurt Jessica Simpson

    [...] Idol winner, Carrie Underwood, is rumored to have said that Jessica Simpson is fat and that Jess’ boyfriend (Carrie’s ex), Tony Romo still [...]

  13. Michele

    Carrie would not call anyone fat. She isn’t the type. I mean I don’t know her but I think she has a little more to worry and think about. All the girl wants to do is sing and enjoy her career. This feud is completely media made. I think Jessica made it more personal than it was because she’s insecure with Tony. She needs to grow up. She’s always has been a little juvenile. Carrie is a nice and decent person from a small town and even though that’s rare in the celebrity world, it’s true. People just want to find dirt on Carrie so she can be known as a bad girl. Leave her alone!!!

  14. Jessica Simpson Fat

    I guess she’s on Tony Romo’s diet… Have you seen the latest pics? Jeez…

  15. Jane

    Anyone who doesn’t think Jessica has packed on a few pounds should go to WKIS.com. She appeared at the Chilli cookoff last weekend and was….well let’s say it wasn’t pretty, visually or vocally to say the least.

  16. psbintl

    She was never “pretty” vocally! Any time I have heard her sing I wanted to shoot myself while running my nails down a blackboard!

    But she has definitely gained weight, which is no crime, she does not look terrible. However, looking and sounding as she does she should not sing or attempt those kind of dance moves. It really looked and sounded horrible!

  17. Michele

    I remember when Carrie Underwood had some weight on her!!! She had to loose some pounds as well. So if she did say that then F her. Jessica doesn’t sing all that well but ya know what she did that all on her own. Not on a show. I say piss on both of them.

  18. Tibbar Grey

    Wow Jessica Simpson let herself go! Its a good thing Nick Lacey dumped that Fat burn out singer and got with that girl from mtv at least she can stay away from the fried foods. Jessica did you think that you could hide your fat under TWO BELTS? Your face alone gained about 30 pounds. She should have posed nude in playboy when she had the body to do so. I bet she has stretch marks

  19. katrono

    1: As if u believe wat magazines say
    2: Jessica simpson isnt fat, she just has put on weight
    3:u people are probably fatter than carrie underwood and Jessica simpson put together.
    4: They both made it as singers and they are more famous than u so stop calling them fat u pathetic retards

  20. Henrietta

    You should see Jessica now. Oh my gawd! She’s huge. I suspect she’ll plump up even more by spring time. Tony probably wishes he was still with Carrie. At least she still looks good.

  21. laurenrvt

    WHO EVER IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE WRITTEN WORK ON THIS SITE, PLEASE REVISE GRAMMAR RULES!

    It’s not, “Carrie and him…” it is, “He and Carrie.”
    This grammar error is everywhere! I have heard it used over the radio, television shows, even over news coverages– keep in mind that all of the above media examples include professionally written scripts. Although this particular error is common and popular, it is not certainly not alone. There are several other grammatical glitches, each one equally as insulting as the next, that have become accepted and normal.

    Have Americans really come to this low point of empty-headed-ignorance where we consider hick-talk as proper diction?

  22. Jeanne

    @laurenvt – Before you continue your tirade about Americans deteriorating into hicks, I’d like to point out that I’m Canadian :)

    Regardless, even the most well-spoken, articulate and grammatically-sound people make mistakes. Surely, you are not immune to this.

    For example, you wrote “it is not certainly not alone.” What is that? It looks like a grammatical error. I point this out, not to humiliate you as you have attempted to do to me, but merely to demostrate the imperfection of us all.

    While it is important to be concerned about grammar, it is EQUALLY important to have good manners. Perhaps, you could brush up on yours.

  23. tffny

    well….i dont care for either of them as far as music but in my opinion jessica isnt fat.those pants were pretty dreadfull though.lmao anywho the tabloids start mess deliberatly between celebs…other wise theyd have nothign to write about.i mean really…think about it.

  24. Ashlee Simpson’s Bird Nose

    No, that was me who called Jessica Simpson fat. It’s disgusting. Jessica Simpson should just do the world a favor and kill herself.

You must be logged in to post a comment.