You know that hot Old Spice guy, Isaiah Mustafa? Well Old Spice has just replaced him with long-hair creeper/romance novel cover model Fabio. Here for your comparison-making pleasure is a Fabio ad, an Isaiah ad, and just for fun a Sesame Street parody of the ads. (Grover is totally cuter than Fabio.)
![]() | Art Crush: The Best Old Spice Guy Fan Art |
![]() | Who Should Old Spice Guy Isaiah Mustafa Go Out With? |
![]() | Video: The Return Of Isaiah Mustafa, Prodigal Old Spice Guy |










Previous Post




I am going to miss that sexy man, he’s the only reason I paid attention to those ads in the first place.