Yesterday, Mary-Kate Olsen wore a black jumper to a screening of 21. Ashley Olsen wore the same black jumper to the Fall 2006 Calvin Klein show at NYC Fashion Week.
I know it isn’t the best picture of Ash to assess, but I did the best I could! Who wore it better? MK or Ash?

I think they both look great just different – mk looking healthy.
Gawker sighting – its funny MK isn’t presenting the row with her – maybe she has taken over the row completely. Its not like MK isnt in NY.
Ashley Olsen
5th Ave & 58th St
Mar 27th, 2008 @ 11am
Ashley Olsen is at Bergdorf Goodman right now in a meeting with the CEO. She did a personal appearance this morning at 9:30am on the 3rd floor to talk about her line The Row. She wore no makeup and looked so naturally sweet and effortlessly pretty. . .leather leggings, white sheer T, grey cashmere cardigan, & 6″ black platforms.
I think Ash wore it best, i pretty much always love MK’s but this one makes her look ( i hate to say it) a bit fat, because its so shapeless hangin over the belt like that…unflattering, ash’s pulled down look is much better
this time I have to admit I prefer ashley.
or maybe it’s mk’s hair that’s wrong… there’s something not right about her shillouette there.
OMG Ashley of course!
Mary Kate looks really bad actually..
i think ashley worked it.
seriously, whats up with mks hair?
and that clutch?
but i really cant say i like ashleys shoes, although overall she is glowing.
to me, this will always be ashley’s outfit. but mk’s belt is still cute.
They both give me a boner.
it’s the shoulders!
Ashley for sure! I mean, MK looks prety and HEALTHY! But Ash work it!
Ash all the way
i actually dont like this outfit… it makes them both look fat. but yeh ash wins cuz her hair is nice …sloz…
Ashley- she looked amazing in it.
Ashöey is the one who knows how to wear it =)
Sorry, Ashley =P I wrote ashöey…
National enquirer has them on the cover but it seems Star Mag has an article on them too.
Star
“Ashley’s isn’t an angel, but she’s tired of having to take care of Mary-Kate,” a spying friend of the pair gushes to Star Magazine. “They used to do everything together-but not anymore! Ashley’s decided she doesn’t want to go down with her.”
as much as i love mary-kate <3333333
ashley looks better
hmmm…. MK looking real healthy not as skinny as previous years. but wats with the hair?
i personally like her with that messy long hair. real nice.
I disagree with Rosie.. Mk doesnt look fat.
She just looks shapeless.
Ashley looks much better, but I would prefer MK’s style since its more.. daring.
Ashley looks more healthy and fresh. But also MK got a bad shot! She could have looked better
Ashley, even though I LOVE MK.
hate to admit it but it’s ash except for the shoe [but it was 2006]
and mk should never wear her hair that way, but like the clutch
I ‘m glad that MK looks healthy lately,I don’t like her hair though. Ashley worked it better-am I the only one who likes her shoes???
mk is looking reeally plump now!
Well they both look radiant ad very chic with this outfit, but I think Ash works it better!
they wore the thing exacxtly the same just mary-kate wore some disgusting coloured hair tie around her waist
I usually like mks looks better then ash but this time i think ashley really rocked it! i remember when ashley wore that, and i didnt even think it was the same thing that mk wore now, because they look completly different in it!