Comments on: Grey's Anatomy Breaking News: No More Dr. Hahn, No More Callica

By: Happy

Happy — Tue, 20 Jan 2009 17:53:52 +0000

I know alot of people that will once again be tuning in to what used to be there favorite show. (And YES we did stop watching!) For as many people that complain about not being able to watch trash, there are many more of us that actually enjoy the drama, comedy and romance that does not include two females gettin it on. (I believe they have channels for that.) Way to go ABC!

By: Moni

Moni — Thu, 01 Jan 2009 17:03:51 +0000

How can this happen in USA? Weren’t you proud about that thing called freedom of speech? Or did it become obsolete?

By: dipipidi

dipipidi — Tue, 16 Dec 2008 10:32:06 +0000

I have to say that I’m extremely disappointed with GA & ABC with these turn of events. I mean, c’mon people! Seriously!?!?!

Brooke Smith was playing the role of Dr. Erica Hahn with conviction and remarkable credibility…& they gave her the boot just like that!?!?! What is up with that? Can’t you recognize a really good actor when you have one? Besides that, the storyline about her & Callie was just getting off the ground!

They were so bent on getting Isaiah Washington off the cast because of his anti-gay booboo, now they axe Brooke/Erica because of the character she plays?! TR Knight may have a point about wanting to get out of GA & ABC…even Joe the Bartender isn’t getting anymore airtime! OMG.

All these actors were/are doing really good jobs portraying their respective characters…but I guess that’s not important, is it?

All in all, I think ABC brass really need to re-evaluate their POVs on gay relationships and its impact on today’s society.

By: Dimples61

Dimples61 — Mon, 15 Dec 2008 08:08:01 +0000

From what I read Brooke is working on a project with the producer David Milch from the show NYPD BLUE. She goes on to say that her firing.
Was what it was. And she has no hard feelings. She is a better person than I am. Cause I”m still pissed over this. LOL!!! Different people have spoke of her being hard, kinda hateful. She played that same hard person on the show Crossing Jordan. But that is just how she plays a part. On one of her interviews while on Grey’s, she said that Dr Hahn is all about the work and didn’t have much of a personal life and she didn’t show lot of emotions. When she did feel emotional about anything she got critized for it. So poor girl couldn’t win. But if you watch any of her videos when she isn’t playing a part that has to be a bad ass. You can see her kindness. Brooke Smith is a sweet ,kind, beautiful person.

By: Shalimar

Shalimar — Fri, 12 Dec 2008 21:51:45 +0000

i don’t think that’s a very good move, since T.R. is planning to leave the show and they didn’t get a golden globe nod (i think this show needs all the help it needs to stay afloat).. erica brought something different and edgy to the show, and the callie/erica relationship should bring a whole new (very much needed) fanbase.

anyways, i love this show and wish it the best of luck!!!

By: AnnasMom07

AnnasMom07 — Fri, 12 Dec 2008 18:08:56 +0000

Mark, I never thought of her in that light, but you are absolutely right about her character portrayal. I can’t wait to see what other projects she is working on (http://www.greysanatomynews.com/2008/12/12/brooke-smith-discusses-life-after-greys/).

By: Mark Robbins

Mark Robbins — Wed, 10 Dec 2008 00:30:29 +0000

I think Brooke Smith was one of the few actors on Grey’s who came across as intelligent enough to be a real doctor. Unfortunately, the story line got too heavy for the right wingnuts, and they probably launched a crusade, possibly through an influential executive, about removing sponsors and the like. American society is still very homophobic. I liked the story line.

By: robin

robin — Sat, 15 Nov 2008 01:18:51 +0000

its so stupid, its not about carry or hahn, or even about a tv show relationship.
we must learn to respect each other for what we are!
come on people its the freakin’ 21ste century!!!

By: The Dimps

The Dimps — Thu, 13 Nov 2008 07:48:26 +0000

I think that maybe the part everyone is calling forced was the part of them not really knowing what they was doing. When you first get with your g/f you don’t really know what your doing. So it might look forced. I have been a lesbian for 47 yrs. I don’t think that I’de ever go to a male friend and get advise on how to have sex with my lesbian g/f. In the heat of passion you figure these things out. There relationship was to fast they should have dated awhile and got to know each other better before they jumped into the sheets. Felt the desire and wanting of each other. And talked to each other about what they wanted, instead of talking to Sloan and Bailey. Those scenes where funny, but not something that actually would have happened. I think that Glaad has alot to learn. And to my way of thinking really messed up. And caused Brooke her job. I’m sure Glaad does alot of wonderful things, but this was not one of them.

By: Guy Herrera

Guy Herrera — Wed, 12 Nov 2008 21:13:07 +0000

6agomk4bk7fp0i7q