We’ve gotten three new episodes in the past three weeks, and after the very long hiatus, I’m curious where you guys stand in terms of favorite episodes. So which of the three that have aired so far did you enjoy the most? Was it “Where the Wild Things Are” the very first episode after the strike? Or was it “Pieces of my Heart” guest starring Kate Walsh? Or maybe last night’s episode really did it for you?
And of course, why was it your favorite?
I haven’t gotten a chance to see last night’s episode yet because I’m away from home, but of the first two, I loved “Pieces of My Heart.” I can’t tell if it was all due to the greatness of having Addison back at Seattle Grace or if it was more than that. But overall, it was a nearly perfect episode for me. I’ll reserve my vote until I can see “The Becoming,” though. What about you?

I simply l o v e d “The Becoming”. I loved both what happened to the doctors and the patients. The story of the two soldiers was simply beautiful. Heartbreaking! Alex is growing too, I loved him in this episode. And Cristina’s speech sequens was wonderful!
One of the best episodes in a really really long time (altough I loved “Pieces of my Heart” too, it was not as good as “The Becoming”.)
I loved the progress between Meredith and Derek. They are the only reason I watch. I live for MerDer!
Although I loved “Pieces of My Heart”, there was just something about “The Becoming” that just grabbed me. I am not sure if it was any one particular storyline, or if it was just the way it all came together. It was just wonderful!
I loved ‘Pieces of my heart’ and even tough the storyline did not advance a great deal, and ‘The Becoming’ was awesome, I just miss Kate Walsh. So PomH it is. Addison rocks.
I think you crossed the line with May 8 episode. The gay thing is getting to be fairly common everywhere, but you do not need to flaunt it in our faces. If you can show me in the Bible where God approves of it, then I will accept it. It is to the point where this show is to see how raunchy or how much sex we can have. SAD