Comments on: Idol Face Off – A Little Less Conversation

By: anonymous

anonymous — Tue, 25 Sep 2007 18:45:18 +0000

Your right LisaLee we dont get Canadian Idol here in the US but, i have to say I really enjoy being able to see them here. I just happened to stumble on Kalan Porters audition on youtube and I LOVED it. What a gorgeous guy and what a gorgeous voice. As for this faceoff I remember when Chris sang this on AI5 and I didn’t particularly love it then and I still dont. Melissa was pretty good but lacked some ooomph, I guess. Not thrilled with either one I’m afraid. I’ll be looking forward to the next pairing!

By: LisaLee

LisaLee — Tue, 25 Sep 2007 00:28:55 +0000

I think a big problem is I don’t think US gets Canadian Idol do they, so a lot of visitors won’t have heard of our singers. And of course most if not all Canadians get American Idol so we ALL know those singers.lol

By: kfc-Canada

kfc-Canada — Mon, 24 Sep 2007 15:59:39 +0000

I think Melissa gave it that ‘one-on-one’ touch with her conversational tone…she was involved with every word she sang. Low-key but convincing.

Chris sounded like he was channeling Elvis…without the charisma..and I didn’t even finish listening to the song…it was so boring.

I vote for Melissa.

By: Bouffe

Bouffe — Mon, 24 Sep 2007 13:55:16 +0000

Well, both Melissa and Chris sang that song really well. So for me, it’ll come down to personal preferences.

So it’s Daughtry for me! I only wish he’d kick in his higher register a bit sooner, but still, I thought that song totally worked for him.