Subscribe
Previous Post
Today’s Idol Face Off has Clay Aiken squaring off against Scott Savol (both American Idol). They both sang “Everlasting Love” – which one do you “love?”
Clay Aiken
Scott Savol
{democracy:90}
Tags: clay aiken, scott savol, everlasting love, idol, face off, stalker, american, american idol, idol stalker, idolstalker
No need for thanks oochie. I did like Scott and was disappointed when he left. He has a good voice. I do think that Clay sings much better, however. I am a big Clay fan, he stole my heart the moment he sang “Take”.
Scott was not a bad singer but he always seemed phony to me. Ruben was the “velvet teddy bear” but Scott was anything but cuddly.
Clay is a very good singer so I guess I’ll vote for him of the two.
I’d have to give it to Clay. I can’t even watch Scott’s all the way through, sorry, where as I can’t stop watching Clay’s
I love both of the two talented guys, they are two different people, two different styles, seems unfair to put one against the other, I’ve been to both of their concerts…but at Scotts… I felt he sang from his soul, he puts everything he has into his music and he touches my heart every time I hear him, I believe this guy has a remarkable talent, its one thing when you have a beautiful voice like Clay, but its another when you can touch the heart and soul of someone in your audience and pull at their heart strings. Scott has that gift…hes amazing!
People might need to remember as well that during season 2 the contestants didn’t have near the freedom to move around, dance or interact as they did in season 4 when Scott was on. By then they even encouraged moving around and had a walkway behind the judges for the contestants to use if they wanted. Season 2 you were pretty much expected to stand there and sing. Plus Simon was still very critical then of those who did try to move or dance or “get into” their numbers. Singing wise, Clay wins hands down.
Two of the best singers ever to appear on Idol!
Clay’s performance was the highlight of the week for me, yet Scotty The Body really sold it in his season. Scott put a wow factor into the song.
I’ve been lucky enough to see both of these sweet guys perform live since Idol, and both are like buttah.
i thank you margaret for your kind words. scott’s not a mean person, he’s very humble & soft spoken. people who want to visit his hometown are always welcome by his family & friends. so for others, give him a break! he’s a spiritual person too & wants every idol like himself to succeed in this music industry. i’m very happy for clay, kelly, carrie, chris, etc… who made this far. they’re all trying to achieve their dream of making IT. someone like ashlee simpson who tries to downgrade the idols (ie blake) should be the one you all need to attack. she’s saying all idols (ALL IDOLS) don’t have any business in the music industry. we know that she’s just popular clinging to the bosom of her other popular sister.
so let’s all promote & enjoy the success of every idol. remember everyone is here to achieve their dreams :)
PEACE!
I liked Scott and I think his voice was good.
Clay on the other hand I love and think his voice is wonderful, beautiful, fantastic, I could go on and on but I think y’all know what I think about Clay’s voice so I’ll stop.
Let’s remember, it’s a singing competition. Clay hands down.
Ok so it was not a good idea for me to watch Clay’s performance first. Because after I was done and started watching Scott, I wanted to stop it and watch Clay’s again.. hahaha
clay had a great transformation & powerful voice. he reminds me of barry manilow. i love his ballad songs but when it came to choosing which of the 2 did better, i’d say scott did. it was fun seeing his goofy side in the intro (john travolta dancing). when i see paula stand up & feeling his performance & then dragged randy to dance too, it meant that she enjoyed his performance a lot & randy did too.
don’t get me wrong clay fans, i also like clay, i thought he should’ve won vs reuben. but judging on this “everlasting love” competition, scott did a better performance.
At that point in the competition Clay didn’t have to move. He had us all at “Mah name’s Clay Aiken”. lol
Seriously, his voice from the start was amazing but the tranformation in his look from week to week was mesmerizing.
Scott did such a tremendous job on this as well as his other Idol performances. Clay is a talent, but is not someone I enjoy viewing or listening to. I am appalled at the wierd personal comments about someone as nice and talented as Scott…love him !
Hands down Clay wins this one!!! Amazing, wonderful performence. Clay can sing anything.
Oh my, not even close.Scott had some pretty decent performances. But thats about it. Clay sang this really, really great. Once again, not much time but still in the time given he was incredibly good. Hard to beat the guy, he can sing like very few.
absolutely no contest! Clay wins this hands down. just Wow listen to that glory note!!!
scott knew this song from the heart & it was a fun song for him, did anyone see paula & randy dancing???? that meant they felt the “groovy jive” scott did a terrific job, with the ending ie pounding his kneee/elbow kinda thing! GROOVY MAN!!! :)
this song was scott’s song & i think he was better off than clay. clay has a powerful voice & he’s very good but watching the youtube video, i will have to give credit to scott, he was feeling the “groove” while clay just stood there & didn’t move much. sorry to if i offended any clay fans, i like clay too. he’s an awesome guy!
Clay is the way, okay…..LOL
Clay all the way!!!Loooove him!!!!!