Comments on: Idol Face Off - "Unchained Melody" http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/ Crushable gives you the celebrity news, style and scoop on the stuff you care about. Fri, 19 Mar 2010 22:26:18 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.1 hourly 1 By: lil http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/comment-page-7/#comment-262748 lil Thu, 05 Mar 2009 13:20:46 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/#comment-262748 Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and just because you mightn't like their opinion, doesn't make their opinion wrong or your opinion right. If I don't like a singer's voice, then I'm entitled to say so and if you happen to like that singer's voice, then you're entitled to say so. It cuts both ways, and not everyone is going to agree all of the time. There are some good Idol singers from time to time and sadly some of these good Idol singers are overlooked while other not so good Idol singers do well although I cannot fathom why. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and just because you mightn’t like their opinion, doesn’t make their opinion wrong or your opinion right. If I don’t like a singer’s voice, then I’m entitled to say so and if you happen to like that singer’s voice, then you’re entitled to say so. It cuts both ways, and not everyone is going to agree all of the time.

There are some good Idol singers from time to time and sadly some of these good Idol singers are overlooked while other not so good Idol singers do well although I cannot fathom why.

]]> By: May http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/comment-page-7/#comment-260517 May Tue, 24 Jun 2008 23:28:47 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/#comment-260517 lil I agree with you, that not everyone will like Clays singing, and that they are entitled to. I do not however agree everyone is entitled to their opinion. Lots of people have opinions on lots of things, they know nothing about. For example, if you are sick you go to a doctor, not your next door neighbor for an opinion, not everyones opinion is right. In this instance people have a right to not like a singer, but that does not make them right. Look at all those bad singers on Idol, they all of the opinion that they can sing, are they right? lil I agree with you, that not everyone will like Clays singing, and that they are entitled to. I do not however agree everyone is entitled to their opinion. Lots of people have opinions on lots of things, they know nothing about. For example, if you are sick you go to a doctor, not your next door neighbor for an opinion, not everyones opinion is right. In this instance people have a right to not like a singer, but that does not make them right. Look at all those bad singers on Idol, they all of the opinion that they can sing, are they right?

]]> By: lil http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/comment-page-7/#comment-260487 lil Tue, 24 Jun 2008 16:20:45 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/#comment-260487 Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Just because you have a different view than someone else doesn't make your opinion any more right than theirs. You like Clay's singing, other people don't. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Just because you have a different view than someone else doesn’t make your opinion any more right than theirs. You like Clay’s singing, other people don’t.

]]> By: May http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/comment-page-7/#comment-259901 May Mon, 16 Jun 2008 08:53:50 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/#comment-259901 OMG cant believe this is still going on, I last posted here in Oct. LOL. Faith, I agree Clay does not need defending, but it really is amusing how people have opinions on what they do NOT know. KartoffMuter is of course right, and so is Jean. Obviously anonymous does not know that Clay is singing to a back up tape. Would have sounded really funny if he had sang it slower. So saying Clay is singing too fast, is pointless and not worth commenting on. OMG cant believe this is still going on, I last posted here in Oct. LOL. Faith, I agree Clay does not need defending, but it really is amusing how people have opinions on what they do NOT know. KartoffMuter is of course right, and so is Jean. Obviously anonymous does not know that Clay is singing to a back up tape. Would have sounded really funny if he had sang it slower. So saying Clay is singing too fast, is pointless and not worth commenting on.

]]> By: FAITH http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/comment-page-7/#comment-259853 FAITH Sun, 15 Jun 2008 15:55:31 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/#comment-259853 Oh Good Lord. It's anonymous opinion that Clay sings it too fast. Personally I love his version but everybody's entitled to their opinion. Stop trying so hard to defend Clay. You're part of the problem. Oh Good Lord. It’s anonymous opinion that Clay sings it too fast. Personally I love his version but everybody’s entitled to their opinion. Stop trying so hard to defend Clay. You’re part of the problem.

]]> By: jean http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/comment-page-7/#comment-259838 jean Sun, 15 Jun 2008 13:41:56 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/#comment-259838 To 'anonymous' regarding your comment that Clay sings this song 'way too fast'; uh...methinks Clay did NOT write the arrangement and sang it the way it was given to him to sing. You can NOT deny Clay's vocals on this song is absolutely incredible and far surpasses those on this poll. America knew Clay was 'THE IDOL' and the best vocalist/performer. Clay didn't 'need' this song to WIN AI2- he won it from the first day of competition and was awarded with 80 percent of the vote every single week; including the final vote (which just may have been more than 80 percent if he had 2-3 phone lines and 4 hours of voting, as all other finalists were given starting in Season 3, to receive every single vote of his that was trying to come in.) To ‘anonymous’ regarding your comment that Clay sings this song ‘way too fast’; uh…methinks Clay did NOT write the arrangement and sang it the way it was given to him to sing. You can NOT deny Clay’s vocals on this song is absolutely incredible and far surpasses those on this poll. America knew Clay was ‘THE IDOL’ and the best vocalist/performer. Clay didn’t ‘need’ this song to WIN AI2- he won it from the first day of competition and was awarded with 80 percent of the vote every single week; including the final vote (which just may have been more than 80 percent if he had 2-3 phone lines and 4 hours of voting, as all other finalists were given starting in Season 3,
to receive every single vote of his that was trying to come in.)

]]> By: patti http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/comment-page-6/#comment-259816 patti Sun, 15 Jun 2008 05:36:01 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/#comment-259816 I have to agree, this is not about the original, no one can replace the original. It is about out of these three who sang it the best. All three had different versions, but if you go on "voice" alone, Clay clearly was the best. I did not like the arrangement but that was what he was given and he did an outstanding job! I have to agree, this is not about the original, no one can replace the original. It is about out of these three who sang it the best. All three had different versions, but if you go on “voice” alone, Clay clearly was the best. I did not like the arrangement but that was what he was given and he did an outstanding job!

]]> By: cookie http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/comment-page-6/#comment-259813 cookie Sun, 15 Jun 2008 04:42:41 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/#comment-259813 If you really want to appreciate someone's talent,and I think its on YOUTUBE, take a look at Clay at David Fosters Gala 2006. I think its called Post Unchained Melody,where David had Clay sing only the part with the falsetto. He does this to him a few times and Clay has no trouble jumping right in - in the middle of the song. I'm going to try and send it to Jeanne. Don't know the link,if I find it I'll be back. If you really want to appreciate someone’s talent,and I think its on YOUTUBE, take a look at Clay at David Fosters Gala 2006. I think its called Post Unchained Melody,where David had Clay sing only the part with the falsetto. He does this to him a few times and Clay has no trouble jumping right in – in the middle of the song. I’m going to try and send it to Jeanne. Don’t know the link,if I find it I’ll be back.

]]> By: KartofflMuter http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/comment-page-6/#comment-259811 KartofflMuter Sun, 15 Jun 2008 04:20:34 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/#comment-259811 For the very last time! The original version is not in the running because they had all the time in the world to get it right. These 3 had one chance. Clay,most particularly,had 2 minutes and 20 seconds of canned music ,not a live band like the other 2. He had to keep up with the tempo it set. Get it? For the very last time! The original version is not in the running because they had all the time in the world to get it right. These 3 had one chance. Clay,most particularly,had 2 minutes and 20 seconds of canned music ,not a live band like the other 2. He had to keep up with the tempo it set.
Get it?

]]> By: anonymous http://crushable.com/entertainment/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/comment-page-6/#comment-259767 anonymous Sat, 14 Jun 2008 16:05:16 +0000 http://www.idolstalker.com/idol-face-off-unchained-melody/#comment-259767 Clay Aiken sings this song way too fast. Clay Aiken sings this song way too fast.

]]>