Comments on: New Judges for Cycle 14? http://crushable.com/entertainment/new-judges-for-cycle-14/ Crushable gives you the celebrity news, style and scoop on the stuff you care about. Thu, 09 Feb 2012 05:58:20 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: milkyaqua http://crushable.com/entertainment/new-judges-for-cycle-14/comment-page-1/#comment-213418 milkyaqua Mon, 23 Nov 2009 16:45:55 +0000 http://topmodelgossip.com/?p=5473#comment-213418 There's no way they get another big name model to do this show. Except for Twiggy, Janice and Paulina were trying to treat the show like an actual modeling competition and look for the best model which wasn't what Tyra was looking for. Frankly, I still don't see Vogue stooping to do ANTM. Also, if 17 is still involved that seems like a conflict of interest somehow. Right now I'm of the opinion that this is just a way to drum up publicity for C14. C13 had the lowest ratings of any cycle so I wouldn't put it past TPTB to have put this stuff out there to get people talking, especially considering that the CW has already denied Kimora's involvement. There’s no way they get another big name model to do this show. Except for Twiggy, Janice and Paulina were trying to treat the show like an actual modeling competition and look for the best model which wasn’t what Tyra was looking for. Frankly, I still don’t see Vogue stooping to do ANTM. Also, if 17 is still involved that seems like a conflict of interest somehow. Right now I’m of the opinion that this is just a way to drum up publicity for C14. C13 had the lowest ratings of any cycle so I wouldn’t put it past TPTB to have put this stuff out there to get people talking, especially considering that the CW has already denied Kimora’s involvement.

]]> By: mach turtle http://crushable.com/entertainment/new-judges-for-cycle-14/comment-page-1/#comment-213496 mach turtle Sun, 22 Nov 2009 14:44:43 +0000 http://topmodelgossip.com/?p=5473#comment-213496 Miss J is my favorite judge, so if they kick him off the panel I'll be extremely disappointed. They do need another permanent judge, but hopefully they'll use another supermodel like Janice, Twiggy or Paulina. I'd love to see one of the former two come back, but I'm not sure how possible that is. Janice was always so much fun, but the terms of her departure from ANTM weren't that amicable. Of course, she has made guest appearances since then, both on ANTM and various other NTMs (remember her drunken tirade on the Finnish version?), and her other show was canceled, so you never know. Twiggy I think actually did have scheduling issues, but maybe ahe'll be able to make more time? Oh well, I can dream. If they had to go with someone completely new, though, I'd like to see Linda Evangelista. That'd be interesting. Miss J is my favorite judge, so if they kick him off the panel I’ll be extremely disappointed. They do need another permanent judge, but hopefully they’ll use another supermodel like Janice, Twiggy or Paulina. I’d love to see one of the former two come back, but I’m not sure how possible that is. Janice was always so much fun, but the terms of her departure from ANTM weren’t that amicable. Of course, she has made guest appearances since then, both on ANTM and various other NTMs (remember her drunken tirade on the Finnish version?), and her other show was canceled, so you never know. Twiggy I think actually did have scheduling issues, but maybe ahe’ll be able to make more time? Oh well, I can dream.

If they had to go with someone completely new, though, I’d like to see Linda Evangelista. That’d be interesting.

]]> By: Erin Balser http://crushable.com/entertainment/new-judges-for-cycle-14/comment-page-1/#comment-213451 Erin Balser Sun, 22 Nov 2009 03:00:45 +0000 http://topmodelgossip.com/?p=5473#comment-213451 I just think Anna would very much want to be in control of the process and Andre's presentation on the show and I don't think that's something Tyra would go for. I feel The September Issue was the same way with the exception of Grace - it was a controlled, tight presentation of Vogue. The brand is so strong that Andre's stint on ANTM would need to be in line with that. At the same time, Vogue seems desperate to become savvier lately, so who knows? I just think Anna would very much want to be in control of the process and Andre’s presentation on the show and I don’t think that’s something Tyra would go for. I feel The September Issue was the same way with the exception of Grace – it was a controlled, tight presentation of Vogue. The brand is so strong that Andre’s stint on ANTM would need to be in line with that.

At the same time, Vogue seems desperate to become savvier lately, so who knows?

]]> By: milkyaqua http://crushable.com/entertainment/new-judges-for-cycle-14/comment-page-1/#comment-213450 milkyaqua Sun, 22 Nov 2009 02:48:05 +0000 http://topmodelgossip.com/?p=5473#comment-213450 I'll believe Talley when I see it. I also don't buy that Wintour would let him within 100 feet of ANTM unless it's as a one-off guest judge slot. The fact that he nor anyone who reps him/Vogue has said anything tells me this is either so far down on their radar as to not have even registered or it's too ridiculous to even be taken seriously. I'm glad the CW refuted Kimora's involvement. She was worthless on C1. She said Elyse was too thin for her (yeah, Elyse was too thin to wear her hoochie designs) which was crazy when you're talking about a model. Miss Jay is the question mark. I wouldn't mind him not being on panel if he went back to actually teaching the girls about runway like he did in the earlier cycles instead of all this silliness he does. He actually seems more helpful on international verions of NTM than he does on ANTM. If any judge should be replaced though it's Nigel as he basically just parrots Tyra and acts as the resident pervert. They do need another permanent judge though that would bring another POV to the panel other than Tyra's; someone who actually made some sense. I’ll believe Talley when I see it. I also don’t buy that Wintour would let him within 100 feet of ANTM unless it’s as a one-off guest judge slot. The fact that he nor anyone who reps him/Vogue has said anything tells me this is either so far down on their radar as to not have even registered or it’s too ridiculous to even be taken seriously. I’m glad the CW refuted Kimora’s involvement. She was worthless on C1. She said Elyse was too thin for her (yeah, Elyse was too thin to wear her hoochie designs) which was crazy when you’re talking about a model. Miss Jay is the question mark. I wouldn’t mind him not being on panel if he went back to actually teaching the girls about runway like he did in the earlier cycles instead of all this silliness he does. He actually seems more helpful on international verions of NTM than he does on ANTM. If any judge should be replaced though it’s Nigel as he basically just parrots Tyra and acts as the resident pervert. They do need another permanent judge though that would bring another POV to the panel other than Tyra’s; someone who actually made some sense.

]]>