Reviews for Do You Know

Have you purchased Jessica Simpson’s debut country album, Do You Know?

It seems to me as if critics have been harsher on Jessica’s new album than perhaps her fans are. Recently I’ve read reviews like these:

Jon Caramancia of the New York Times gave the album 2 1/2 stars and said:

“Ignore that this album was made by Simpson, and it’s still utterly competent. Acknowledge that — especially given her history of making unmemorable pop songs — and it almost qualifies as an accomplishment. Almost.”

Monica Cady from LiveDaily said:

“Do You Know” is a sweet, easy-moving collection of songs that never really conjure up any strong emotions. While Simpson has certainly mastered the art of singing, she may need to spend a little more time in Nashville to get some genuine country spirit into her music.”

She also said, “Do You Know,” forgoes rich storytelling and genuine heart in exchange for pop-driven, nondescript vocal showcases.”

Rolling Stone gave Do You Know three out of five stars, and said “digging into her country roots for Do You Know is the most strong-footed move that Jessica Simpson — or her ever-present dad-ager, Joe — has ever made.”

Entertainment Weekly gave Jess a C+, saying:

“…while it’s nice to hear her pipes free of breathless pop production, it’s a shame she ran with such bland, emotionally self-indulgent material for Do You Know. And though teaming up with frequent Carrie Underwood songwriter Hillary Lindsey for five tracks was a savvy move, we already have a Carrie Underwood, honey…and she probably turned these songs down.”

The more I read these reviews, the more I see a theme. Reviewers seem to refer back to Jess’ pop roots, making a transition to country something that will take more than a record or two. I see a couple references, which in the light of the “Real Girls Eat Meet” whoopla could mean people are blaming Jess for that made up little rivalry, and I see some reviewers that just don’t seem to believe Jess is in country for the long haul.

Jessica has done a remarkable job with pre-album interviews and appearances, though. Here’s a typical interview she’s done, where she talks about the new album, the recording process, and whether her crossover effort will be a success:

Her fans, however, may make all these somewhat reviews a mute point. While some are complaining that Jessica’s pop background is coming through a little too much on Do You Know, other fans may think it’s a good thing. That she hasn’t “strayed” too much from what people have already loved about her music in the past. I’m curious to hear from her fans. Have you purchased Do You Know? And if so, what do you think?