Here’s today’s second match-up, Cycle 4’s Michelle Deighton, who recently had a child with Survivor’s Johnny Fairplay. She made it overseas to South Africa during her Cycle, and came in sixth place.
Stacy-Ann was on the most recent Cycle and came seventh.
The full face-off is below the jump!
Michelle Deighton

Image details: VH1 Big In ‘05 Awards – Arrivals served by picapp.com
Michelle, a 19-year-old student from Illnois when she appeared on the show, did quite well. She made it overseas to South Africa and was eliminated in the ninth episode of the season. She was eliminated due to her supposed lack of confidence. She’s since gone on to semi-reality fame, is in a relationship with fellow reality star Johnny Fairplay, and is signed with Janice Dickinson’s modeling agency. If you remember, Michelle was the girl who came down with “flesh eating bacteria” while living in the Top Model house. She was a great model and was very versatile.
Here’s a video portfolio of some of her work:
Stacy-Ann Fequiere

© 2008 The CW Network, LLC. All Rights Reserved
Oh Stacy-Ann. The bubbly 22-year-old student from Florida. She was eliminated right before traveling to the overseas destination because the judges thought that she had the least potential and the weakest portfolio in the bottom two. While Stacy-Ann was bubbly sweet and killed during the go-sees challenge, her photos were never strong enough to make her stand out in the crowd. I lover her makeover, but she certainly didn’t!
Here’s a tribute video dedicated to Stacy-Ann and the many moments she brought us:

Michelle for me. She has a unique beauty with her strong features that make it work for her. I just wish she’d do more modelling than venturing out in reality tv world. As for Stacy Ann, she looks as cute as a button, but she’s not very strong in her photos as Michelle.